An article in yesterday's New York Times (free via CNet) about Microsoft's manic goal to file 3,000 patents a year (and they're on track, incredibly) is up front about certain of its prejudices (the author is for open source development and a ban on software patents), but some of the prejudices that bother me are more subliminal. Take this paragraph:
"Abolishing software patents would be a very good thing," says Daniel Ravicher, executive director of the Public Patent Foundation, a nonprofit group in New York that challenges what it calls "wrongly issued" patents. Ravicher, a patent lawyer himself, says he believes that the current system actually impedes the advance of software technology, at the same time that it works quite nicely to enrich patent holders. That's not what the framers of the Constitution wanted, he said.
So, am I hearing Ravicher right: Is enriching patent holders a problem? Is the underlying message that the pursuit of wealth is somehow improper? Was Jefferson really a commie? Oh dear.
This kind of statement frightens and angers me. As an artist, I have first-hand experience of trying to toil in an area of human endeavor that our culture has declared to be "above" issues of commerce. Our cultural bylaws state that you can't make "true" art to make money (though if you're lucky you can make a lot of it by accident). Artists themselves wrote these bylaws--they ghettoize themselves by frowning upon commerce, and ultimately marginalize themselves by being "above" the market. I see it as a form of self-loathing. It's part of why I grew disillusioned with the arts. So when I see software folks gleefully building themselves an ivory tower and preparing to climb up and throw away the key, I feel dismay in the pit of my stomach.
In short, I'm tired of always seeing the debate over open source v. patents framed in terms of gentle communalists vs. evil capitalists. To me, the real underlying issues are far more mundane, and far more fascinating.
First, here's what I have always taken as the true role of the patent in our culture: Before patents, businesses were only able to protect their turf through secrecy. Trade secrets create lots of problems from industrial espionage to product safety ("Whaddya mean peanuts are part of your secret recipe? You coulda killed me."). They also stifle innovation.
What? Most who argue against patents say that patents stifle innovation--but in fact, patents offer the very protections that allow all of our innovations to be published and shared openly. You may not be free to use someone's patented idea--but because it's patented, you are free to read it, and learn. The patent library is a public record of our collective innovations. And if you want to use the technology, you can--but you must pay a licensing fee or strike a deal with the patent holder.
This is a supremely civil system. Why shouldn't the inventor receive the financial benefits of his or her idea for a period of time? And why shouldn't we all be gentlemen and -women about it and pay each other, while maintaining the open flow of our greatest capital--our ideas. If you ask me, the right to patent is right up there with freedom of the press.
There's a logical absurdity to saying that we should revert to secrecy in order to be free. Secrecy is necessary only if you have no legal recourse, i.e., if it's legal to steal someone's work. And just because it worked in the early days of software development isn't to say it is the system that should be institutionalized. No more than saying we should still settle arguments by duelling with pistols they way they did in the Old West.
Now, is Microsoft out of control? Absolutely. Is the hyperproliferation of software patents creating obstacles for developers? To be sure. And a system that worked for widgets might now work well for something like software. But there is a baby in that bathwater!
It seems to me that what we need is a new category of intellecutal property. What about a five year term of protection and a streamlined filing process--enough to let software developers get to market? What about a semi-open system based on a retail model, where anyone who wanted to use your software could, but had to bid for the license fee on an open market (rather than liciencing through laboriously negotiated deals)? Affordable, automated licensing could help enrich patent holders (expecially via the Long Tail) while maintaining the free flow of ideas.
I may have to think some more about what kind of system would work best. But one thing's for certain: if I do come up with a new way to issue patent software, the first thing I'm going to do is file a method patent.
ADDENDUM: Just read this from Mike Masnick on the Globalization Institute blog:
Isn't it time we started looking at real solutions for patent reform that recognize the fact that the current system obviously can't scale? This certainly suggests that a system of peer reviewed patentsthat allowed various experts in the field to weigh in on patents could work better. Other ideas include a more "open source" approach - where patent applications are published much earlier along with an easy way for anyone in the public to object to the patent and provide prior art. These are solutions that distribute the work outwards and aren't relying on the same patent examiner system that obviously cannot handle the load created by our existing approach to patents.
I'm not sure how people got the idea that when you get an idea, you have some sort of right to have the government guarantee that you profit from it exclusively, for any length of time. Perhaps they should patent that idea. There's no real evidence that patent protection, any more than any other government project, advances innovation or progress. The process introduces many distortions and much waste.
And (grammatical note): "man" means "man or woman", when used non-specifically. Why waste words?
Posted by: Robert Speirs | March 23, 2006 at 06:10 AM
http://www.vashdivan77.ru/ диваны ужас!купил диван лика .Но так как проработал 4 года на фабрике по производству мебели решил посмотреть из чего сделан диванчик.И было очень интересно-себестоимость и качество комплектующих.)))все комплектующие-фуфло ролики 5 руб штука.расчитаные на нагрузку 15 кг.Крепление спинок-самопальные штыри.Добравшись-до внутренности подлокотников-остолбинел,собран из реального мусора строительного производства,углы спинок не проложены ппу и синтепоном,можно хорошенько долбануться-веском или ребёнок головой налетит(((Себестоимость 2 подлокотников штыри-7 руб пара.Дермантин для обивки дверей-3 п.м -китай-150-170 п.м.=ппу -низкого качества с громатным содержанием мела.Продолжаем дальше.Подушки-забиты переработкой-синтетической промышленности плюс передробленный -поролон.Каркас-фанера 4-5 класса 300 руб лист.Всё хорошенько-прикрыто спец тканью 18 руб п.м.Рогожка-производства китай.В трусиках не посидишь-прыщи повылазат...аллергия обеспеченна....Сиденья-молния сразу заклинила.Блин -такой конструкции я не видел)))))1 мм проволка скрученная в пружину связанные проволкой между собой.Проложен-под пружины фётр .прессованный картон.И проклеен поролон 25мм=хотя минимальный допуск 30-35мм..Пружина в попу.скрип.промятость. через 2-3 месяца-100% гарантирована!!!.НЕ будем продолжать !!!но хочу озвучить себестоимость 4500-5000.Китай +2 сортный материал+кривые руки-гарантия дешёвой аллергии.Ребята-поучитесь у фабрик 8 марта.маон.и ник.5 звёзд....Репутация превыше выгоды.Для-покупателей если вы думаете что я кокурент или пытаюсь аххаять -то вы не правы.У вас есть возможность проверить но своей коже.Удачи.В выборе.скупой платит дважды-трижды.Радуйтесь-покупками.
Posted by: apannentiet | September 21, 2011 at 12:50 AM
A rolling stone gathers no moss.
safe disc region free copy protected cd
Posted by: clonecd361 | December 16, 2011 at 12:53 AM
Our company has years of experience producing fake passports and other identity documents. We use high quality equipment and materials to produce counterfeit passports. All secret features of real passports are carefully duplicated for our falsified documents.
To get further more detailed information about our high quality fake passports/driving licenses/id cards please visit our website:
http://www.falsepassports.cc /ht tp:/ /w ww.falsepassports .cc
To order our fake documents please send your enquiries to our E-mail:
General support: [email protected]
Technical support: [email protected]
http://falsepassports.cc/inside/pp-uk-open-big.jpg
http://falsepassports.cc/inside/pp-br-open-big.jpg
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-(Key words)-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
false fake passports for sale of Afghanistan
false fake passports for sale of Albania
false fake passports for sale of Algeria
false fake passports for sale of Andorra
false fake passports for sale of Angola
false fake passports for sale of Antigua & Deps
false fake passports for sale of Argentina
false fake passports for sale of Armenia
false fake passports for sale of Australia
false fake passports for sale of Austria
false fake passports for sale of Azerbaijan
false fake passports for sale of Bahamas
false fake passports for sale of Bahrain
false fake passports for sale of Bangladesh
false fake passports for sale of Barbados
false fake passports for sale of Belarus
false fake passports for sale of Belgium
false fake passports for sale of Belize
false fake passports for sale of Benin
false fake passports for sale of Bhutan
false fake passports for sale of Bolivia
false fake passports for sale of Bosnia Herzegovina
false fake passports for sale of Botswana
false fake passports for sale of Brazil
false fake passports for sale of Brunei
false fake passports for sale of Bulgaria
false fake passports for sale of Burkina
false fake passports for sale of Burundi
false fake passports for sale of Cambodia
false fake passports for sale of Cameroon
false fake passports for sale of Canada
false fake passports for sale of Cape Verde
false fake passports for sale of Central African Rep
false fake passports for sale of Chad
false fake passports for sale of Chile
false fake passports for sale of China
false fake passports for sale of Colombia
false fake passports for sale of Comoros
false fake passports for sale of Congo
false fake passports for sale of Congo Democratic Rep
false fake passports for sale of Costa Rica
false fake passports for sale of Croatia
false fake passports for sale of Cuba
false fake passports for sale of Cyprus
false fake passports for sale of Czech Republic
false fake passports for sale of Denmark
false fake passports for sale of Djibouti
false fake passports for sale of Dominica
false fake passports for sale of Dominican Republic
false fake passports for sale of East Timor
false fake passports for sale of Ecuador
false fake passports for sale of Egypt
false fake passports for sale of El Salvador
false fake passports for sale of Equatorial Guinea
false fake passports for sale of Eritrea
false fake passports for sale of Estonia
false fake passports for sale of Ethiopia
false fake passports for sale of Fiji
false fake passports for sale of Finland
false fake passports for sale of France
false fake passports for sale of Gabon
false fake passports for sale of Gambia
false fake passports for sale of Georgia
false fake passports for sale of Germany
false fake passports for sale of Ghana
false fake passports for sale of Greece
false fake passports for sale of Grenada
false fake passports for sale of Guatemala
false fake passports for sale of Guinea
false fake passports for sale of Guinea-Bissau
false fake passports for sale of Guyana
false fake passports for sale of Haiti
false fake passports for sale of Honduras
false fake passports for sale of Hungary
false fake passports for sale of Iceland
false fake passports for sale of India
false fake passports for sale of Indonesia
false fake passports for sale of Iran
false fake passports for sale of Iraq
false fake passports for sale of Ireland Republic
false fake passports for sale of Israel
false fake passports for sale of Italy
false fake passports for sale of Ivory Coast
false fake passports for sale of Jamaica
false fake passports for sale of Japan
false fake passports for sale of Jordan
false fake passports for sale of Kazakhstan
false fake passports for sale of Kenya
false fake passports for sale of Kiribati
false fake passports for sale of Korea North
false fake passports for sale of Korea South
false fake passports for sale of Kosovo
false fake passports for sale of Kuwait
false fake passports for sale of Kyrgyzstan
false fake passports for sale of Laos
false fake passports for sale of Latvia
false fake passports for sale of Lebanon
false fake passports for sale of Lesotho
false fake passports for sale of Liberia
false fake passports for sale of Libya
false fake passports for sale of Liechtenstein
false fake passports for sale of Lithuania
false fake passports for sale of Luxembourg
false fake passports for sale of Macedonia
false fake passports for sale of Madagascar
false fake passports for sale of Malawi
false fake passports for sale of Malaysia
false fake passports for sale of Maldives
false fake passports for sale of Mali
false fake passports for sale of Malta
false fake passports for sale of Marshall Islands
false fake passports for sale of Mauritania
false fake passports for sale of Mauritius
false fake passports for sale of Mexico
false fake passports for sale of Micronesia
false fake passports for sale of Moldova
false fake passports for sale of Monaco
false fake passports for sale of Mongolia
false fake passports for sale of Montenegro
false fake passports for sale of Morocco
false fake passports for sale of Mozambique
false fake passports for sale of Myanmar, Burma
false fake passports for sale of Namibia
false fake passports for sale of Nauru
false fake passports for sale of Nepal
false fake passports for sale of Netherlands
false fake passports for sale of New Zealand
false fake passports for sale of Nicaragua
false fake passports for sale of Niger
false fake passports for sale of Nigeria
false fake passports for sale of Norway
false fake passports for sale of Oman
false fake passports for sale of Pakistan
false fake passports for sale of Palau
false fake passports for sale of Panama
false fake passports for sale of Papua New Guinea
false fake passports for sale of Paraguay
false fake passports for sale of Peru
false fake passports for sale of Philippines
false fake passports for sale of Poland
false fake passports for sale of Portugal
false fake passports for sale of Qatar
false fake passports for sale of Romania
false fake passports for sale of Russian Federation
false fake passports for sale of Rwanda
false fake passports for sale of St Kitts & Nevis
false fake passports for sale of St Lucia
false fake passports for sale of Saint Vincent & the Grenadines
false fake passports for sale of Samoa
false fake passports for sale of San Marino
false fake passports for sale of Sao Tome & Principe
false fake passports for sale of Saudi Arabia
false fake passports for sale of Senegal
false fake passports for sale of Serbia
false fake passports for sale of Seychelles
false fake passports for sale of Sierra Leone
false fake passports for sale of Singapore
false fake passports for sale of Slovakia
false fake passports for sale of Slovenia
false fake passports for sale of Solomon Islands
false fake passports for sale of Somalia
false fake passports for sale of South Africa
false fake passports for sale of Spain
false fake passports for sale of Sri Lanka
false fake passports for sale of Sudan
false fake passports for sale of Suriname
false fake passports for sale of Swaziland
false fake passports for sale of Sweden
false fake passports for sale of Switzerland
false fake passports for sale of Syria
false fake passports for sale of Taiwan
false fake passports for sale of Tajikistan
false fake passports for sale of Tanzania
false fake passports for sale of Thailand
false fake passports for sale of Togo
false fake passports for sale of Tonga
false fake passports for sale of Trinidad & Tobago
false fake passports for sale of Tunisia
false fake passports for sale of Turkey
false fake passports for sale of Turkmenistan
false fake passports for sale of Tuvalu
false fake passports for sale of Uganda
false fake passports for sale of Ukraine
false fake passports for sale of United Arab Emirates
false fake passports for sale of United Kingdom
false fake passports for sale of United States
false fake passports for sale of Uruguay
false fake passports for sale of Uzbekistan
false fake passports for sale of Vanuatu
false fake passports for sale of Vatican City
false fake passports for sale of Venezuela
false fake passports for sale of Vietnam
false fake passports for sale of Yemen
false fake passports for sale of Zambia
false fake passports for sale of Zimbabwe
=========================================================================
how to make birth certificates,birth certificate identification,how to make a student id card,picture id template,novelty student card,how to make a fake id easy,driving licence proof identity,buy id holograms,cards created through theidshop,fake college id templates
Posted by: guepPymmelm | June 05, 2012 at 12:56 AM
online pharmacy http://www.powellentertainment.net/swd/index.php?showuser=5151 Buy discount viagra
Posted by: zrMonichemari | October 23, 2012 at 04:04 PM